On Immigration and Being American
The immigration issue has become a hot button topic in this years election cycle. It is couched in a variety of ways: national security; legal fairness; labor rights; economic development; multicultural(xenophobia). I suspect it is part of a larger issue, namely a national struggle to answer the question of what it is to be an American.
America was founded on five basic principles: 1- Equality (of opportunity not outcome), 2- Liberty, 3- Individualism, 4- Populism (as opposed to elitism), 5- Laissez -faire. These principles have become assaulted by misguided people who yearn for a "fairer" system; perhaps modeled on a Euro-style socialist system. The result of this trend is to force equal outcomes through employment/enrollment quotas; promotion of groups (gay, Hispanic, etc) rights rather than their respective individual rights as human beings; the propagation of elitist thinking in the press and our universities over the general will of the people. This struggle has been going on for some time, it is has only recently been focused sharply on the American consciousness through the immigration debate.
The immigration issue is divisive precisely because we are divided on our own identity. If we can not agree on a national identity than the new arrivals will have nothing to aspire to and integrate with, hence further weakening the foundation that has made us great. It is this that we fear and it is this issue that we must address.
In fact, we as Republicans have been standing in the breech on these very issues for sometime. Regrettably we allow others to twist our arguments to make them sound elitist or heartless. More regrettably, we ourselves have narrowly redefined these issues to suit factions within the party. It is increasingly imperative that our message be unified, informed and articulate not so much on immigration but on equality of opportunity; liberty; individuality; populism and laissez-faire. We must do so not to win elections but so we may preserve our system of government for our children and grandchildren.
To read more on this issue, especially as relates to Islamic immigration in Europe and the parallels to us read: http://www.journalofdemocracy.org/articles/gratis/Fukuyama-17-2.pdf
America was founded on five basic principles: 1- Equality (of opportunity not outcome), 2- Liberty, 3- Individualism, 4- Populism (as opposed to elitism), 5- Laissez -faire. These principles have become assaulted by misguided people who yearn for a "fairer" system; perhaps modeled on a Euro-style socialist system. The result of this trend is to force equal outcomes through employment/enrollment quotas; promotion of groups (gay, Hispanic, etc) rights rather than their respective individual rights as human beings; the propagation of elitist thinking in the press and our universities over the general will of the people. This struggle has been going on for some time, it is has only recently been focused sharply on the American consciousness through the immigration debate.
The immigration issue is divisive precisely because we are divided on our own identity. If we can not agree on a national identity than the new arrivals will have nothing to aspire to and integrate with, hence further weakening the foundation that has made us great. It is this that we fear and it is this issue that we must address.
In fact, we as Republicans have been standing in the breech on these very issues for sometime. Regrettably we allow others to twist our arguments to make them sound elitist or heartless. More regrettably, we ourselves have narrowly redefined these issues to suit factions within the party. It is increasingly imperative that our message be unified, informed and articulate not so much on immigration but on equality of opportunity; liberty; individuality; populism and laissez-faire. We must do so not to win elections but so we may preserve our system of government for our children and grandchildren.
To read more on this issue, especially as relates to Islamic immigration in Europe and the parallels to us read: http://www.journalofdemocracy.org/articles/gratis/Fukuyama-17-2.pdf
